Audamir

Tile shapes: strategy in brief

The shape of a tile sets how many neighbours it has, so how many sides it can be attacked from. This page sums up the series on ten shapes: what holds on every shape and what the measurements show.

The screen of Free play: the templates, the tabs of the settings, the size and the shape of the map and the score for a win
Templates are at the top and the tabs of the settings below them; the score for a win at the bottom changes with the size and the shape of the map.

The shape of a tile is set in Free play and maps. It changes the number of neighbours, and so the number of sides from which a tile can be attacked. The numbers come from the game's code and from measurements of AI on the human seat, not from games of people. The series starts with (forthcoming article no. 73).

Rules that hold on every shape

  • An attack goes only to a neighbour across a shared edge. A touch at a corner is not enough.
  • An attack needs at least two dice. All dice roll, and a tie goes to the defender.
  • After an attack, one die stays on the tile the attack came from.
  • Income at the end of a turn is the number of tiles in the largest connected region.

The shapes in brief

ShapeNeighboursWhat it means
Triangle3The fewest contacts, but thin links. Losing a cut tile costs up to three tiles of income.
Square4Straightforward attack and defence. Win rates are close to the hexagon.
Rhombus4Three rhombi around a vertex form a cube. The largest loss of income among the four-sided shapes.
Brick6As many neighbours as the hexagon, but staggered rows. Win rates are almost the same.
Hexagon6The default shape and the baseline of the measurements.
Octagon8Small squares have four neighbours. A territory does not split when one tile is lost.
Pentagon5Cairo tiling. The territory is stable, win rates are close to the hexagon.
Heptagon7Four heptagons and three filler triangles around each heptagon. The measurements are older.
Nonagon9The most contacts: a territory of 20 tiles has 40. The measurements are older.
Random territories1 to 9Irregular groups of small hexagons. The games are the shortest, 21 to 22 rounds.

What the measurements show

  • The strong AI (level 3) wins between 34% and 37.5% on every shape. No shape differs from the hexagon by more than 2.7 points.
  • The normal AI (level 2) wins from 12.9% (brick) to 20.9% (triangle). It does best on triangles and random territories.
  • The dice limit, the defence bonus and an archipelago change the win rates more than the shape does.

What cannot be measured yet

  • The shape and the number of tiles cannot be separated. A triangle board has 115 tiles, a hexagon board 65.
  • The measurements of the heptagon and the nonagon come from an older geometry. The numbers need to be measured again.
  • The pentagon with eight edge types is not in the main version of the game.